When one thinks about the cultural landscape of the United States, it’s easy to get lost in the bright lights of New York City, the beaches of California, or the jazz of New Orleans. However, if you venture into the heart of Kentucky, a different narrative unfolds—one steeped in tradition, flavor, and pride. Growing up in the buckle of the Bluegrass, the essence of life in Louisville during the 1970s and ’80s revolved around three critical cornerstones: the Kentucky Derby, college basketball, and, most captivatingly, bourbon. These elements were omnipresent, shaping a unique identity that revolved around local celebration. It’s fascinating to reflect upon the surprise that greeted me upon leaving the state—a lack of recognition for bourbon that contradicted my lived experience.
For decades, bourbon was seen as a regional specialty, often misidentified or overlooked entirely in favor of other whiskey variations. This misunderstanding, however, has significantly diminished in recent years. Today, bourbon has blossomed into a global phenomenon, gracing the palates of aficionados across the world. The revival can be attributed to a growing appreciation for craftsmanship and the distinctive nuances of bourbon’s flavor profile. While purists may contend that true bourbon can only originate from Kentucky, where approximately 95% is distilled, the reality is that exceptional distillers have emerged nationwide, each producing unique and high-quality spirits.
The burgeoning bourbon production landscape is noteworthy, with over 850 distilleries operating across the United States. Each distillery contributes to a treasure trove of offerings that challenge the notion of finding a single “best” bourbon. Instead, the variety allows for exploration and discovery, catering to individual tastes and preferences while offering a taste of American heritage. In this spirit of exploration, I consulted esteemed industry experts and competitions to pinpoint the finest bourbons of 2024, each of which promises to elevate any collector’s selection or personal bar.
As an illustration of bourbon’s elevation within the spirits community, the World Whiskies Awards serves as a benchmark for discerning palates. Founded by Whiskey Magazine in 2007, the competition this year involved over 1,500 bottles and 200 judges. Their top pick for the world’s best bourbon was the 1792 12-Year-Old, an exceptional creation by the renowned Sazerac at the Barton Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky. Judges praised its complexity, noting the harmonious balance of flavors, including sweet chocolate and caramel combined with smooth apricot on the finish. Such accolades confirm bourbon’s deserved place in the pantheon of spirits.
However, the accolades do not end there. The International Wine and Spirit Competition highlighted the Kentucky Peerless Distilling Co. High Rye Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey for their Bourbon Trophy 2024. This family-owned distillery, having redefined its presence after its relaunch in 2017, has garnered attention for its unique mash bill incorporating a higher percentage of rye. The judges resonated with its inviting aromas of smoky campfire embers and its rich, baking-spice flavor, providing a delightful drinking experience that transcends the ordinary.
Notably, the Bartender Spirits Awards, a competition anchored in real-world feedback from those within the industry, has identified the Varchas Reserve 102 Straight Bourbon Whiskey from Shankard Distillery in Michigan as their Bourbon of the Year for 2024. Scoring an impressive 97 out of 100 points, its flavor profile combines elements of cooked fruit, oranges, and a complex array of spices—ideal for sipping neat or mixing into cocktails.
Moreover, the New York World Spirits Competition shone a spotlight on Colonel E.H. Taylor Single Barrel Bourbon, winning Best Single Barrel Bourbon under ten years old. Produced by the illustrious Buffalo Trace Distillery, this bourbon’s profile includes rich notes of butterscotch and toasted oak, culminating in a full-bodied finish that exemplifies the depth and character of quality whiskey.
Lastly, the prestigious San Francisco World Spirits Competition awarded Pure Antique 20-Year Straight Bourbon the title of Best Overall Bourbon. This exquisite bourbon, originating from a small Preservation distillery in Bardstown, is a coveted choice that combines rich caramel and dark chocolate flavors with a hint of spice—making it a prized addition to any connoisseur’s collection.
The journey through these acclaimed bourbons is not solely about alcohol; it encapsulates a rich tapestry of American culture and craftsmanship. Each bottle tells a story, woven from tradition and innovation. As bourbon continues to captivate the hearts of drinkers worldwide, the celebration of this unique spirit reminds us of the importance of heritage and the pleasure found in every sip. Whether you’re at a local bar or adding to your collection, embracing bourbon is embracing a slice of history that both delights and unites. In a world of diverse tastes, bourbon remains a figure of pride, representing the very essence of Kentucky and its enduring legacy.
Leave a Reply